Top Trades: November 10 - November 17

Harvey McGuinness • November 19, 2026

Carnivorous Cultivator | Illustrated by Martina Fačková

Howdy, folks! Welcome back to Top Trades, the weekly series here at Cardsphere where we check in with some of the most popular cards making their way across the site. So, with Star Trek newly released, what cards are moving around this week? Let's take a look!

Honorable Mention - Sphinx's Approach

Number of Trades: 8 --- Number of Cards Traded: 33

Kicking things off this week is a card that practically announces what deck is being run the second it hits the stack: Sphinx's Approach.

For , Sphinx's Approach is an instant that lets you draw two cards. Then, you may exile it and four cards named Sphinx’s Approach from your graveyard. If you do, search your library for a Sphinx creature card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle. And yes, just like the other its main-multiverse inspiration, Dragon's Approach, a deck can have any number of cards named Sphinx’s Approach.

That’s the sort of text that gets brewers moving fast. At base rate, this is already a serviceable draw spell. Once you start chaining copies together, though, it turns into a dedicated payoff engine for Sphinx typal decks, allowing players to readily cheat out monstrous creatures at instant speed. Thirty-three copies traded tells the story pretty well: when a card asks players to pick up a stack rather than a singleton, it tends to show up here in a hurry.

#5 - Tarmogoyf

Number of Trades: 6 --- Number of Cards Traded: 6

Coming in at number five is an old favorite that needs no introduction: Tarmogoyf.

For , Tarmogoyf is a Lhurgoyf creature whose power is equal to the number of card types among cards in all graveyards and whose toughness is equal to that number plus one. Simple, efficient, and historically terrifying.

Now, this isn’t 2014, and Tarmogoyf isn’t the boogeyman it once was. That said, efficient graveyard-scaling threats never really go fully out of style, especially when a new printing puts one of the game’s most recognizable creatures back in front of players. Between longtime fans, Cube players, and anyone looking to update a graveyard-centric deck with a fresh copy, let's all take a moment to appreciate this infamous creature's return to the spotlight.

#4 - Simulacrum Shaper

Number of Trades: 6 --- Number of Cards Traded: 7

Next up is Simulacrum Shaper, who really does just answer the question "What if Solemn Simulacrum was green?"

For , Simulacrum Shaper is a 2/2 Elf Druid. When it enters, you may search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle. Then, when it dies, you draw a card.

That’s a pretty tidy package. Ramp on the way in, card back on the way out, and a body left over in the middle. Green decks are always in the market for creatures that smooth out early development without becoming useless later on, and this one does that well. It’s not hard to imagine this showing up in blink decks, sacrifice shells, or just any of green's a-million-and-one Commander lists that want their ramp stapled to something a little more flexible than a sorcery.

#3 - Carnivorous Cultivator

Number of Trades: 6 --- Number of Cards Traded: 8

At number three, we’ve got another Reality Fracture card that does a nice job of looking fair right up until you start thinking about what decks actually want it for: Carnivorous Cultivator.

Carnivorous Cultivator costs for a 2/3 Elf Warlock creature with deathtouch. It enters prepared, and whenever it deals combat damage to a player, you return target land card from your graveyard to your hand. Its prepared spell is Enroot, a sorcery for that lets you search your library for a land card, put it into your graveyard, then shuffle.

There’s a lot going on here for two mana. Deathtouch makes it annoying to block, Enroot sets up whatever land-based nonsense you’re interested in, and the combat trigger gives you a way to start buying those lands back. That’s a pretty natural fit for land-recursion decks, graveyard value shells, and slower green Commander lists that are happy to turn utility lands into a real engine.

On the broken end of the spectrum, Enroot is the real star of the show here, as there are plenty of decks that care more about getting lands into the graveyard right away than you might imagine. Just ask Lumra, Bellow of the Woods about how powerful the graveyard can be in a lands-matter cEDH build.

#2 - Pia, Aether Ascetic

Number of Trades: 8 --- Number of Cards Traded: 11

Just missing the top spot this week is Pia, Aether Ascetic, the card that gave green a way to tutor for Rhystic Study and Underworld Breach, among other things.

For , Pia, Aether Ascetic is a 2/2 legendary Human Druid creature with “When Pia enters, you may discard a card. If you do, search your library for an enchantment card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle.”

Simply put, there are plenty of green decks out there with absolutely broken enchantments and no good way to find them. Pia answers that problem easily, as being a creature herself means that she's green's most naturally tutorable target.

#1 - Geist of Saint Thalia

Number of Trades: 11 --- Number of Cards Traded: 11

Last but not least, our most traded card of the week is the incredibly versatile and efficient Geist of Saint Thalia.

For , Geist of Saint Thalia is a 1/2 legendary Spirit Cleric creature with flying that reduces the cost of noncreature spells you cast by .

Magic is a game all about efficiency, and Thalia here is a two-mana pick that immediately tilts that core aspect of the game in your favor. Decks built around cheap interaction, cantrips, artifacts, enchantments, or spellslinger-style value chains are always interested in effects like this, and putting that ability on a cheap blue legend only raises the ceiling. In short, Thalia's efficient, flexible, and easy to slot into all kinds of Commander builds, which is usually a recipe for popularity.

Wrap Up

Well, folks, that does it for this week's Top Trades. Star Trek may have hit the market, but it seems that Reality Fracture is still where all the popularity is centered. Check back next week to see what new is going on here at Cardsphere, and thanks for reading!