10 Most Valuable Devil Cards

Dance with Devils | Illustrated by Wayne England

While the ever-popular Angel creature type hails from Magic’s inception, the Devil creature type is nowhere near as populated. The first Devil card was found in Magic’s first expansion, Arabian Nights, but then one wasn’t printed again until 2006’s Dissension unveiled Squealing Devil and 2008’s Shards of Alara releasing Scourge Devil.

With Angels boasting well over 250 unique creatures across the game’s history, Devils are way behind that mark at roughly 57 total creatures, but which are the most valuable? Let’s take a look. Just, please, try to hold onto your soul while reading this.

10. Hellrider – Jumpstart

Market Price: $2.35

A fun 3/3 Devil with haste originally from 2012’s Dark Ascension, this version hails from 2020’s Jumpstart and is worth far more than the original copy of the card.

Pinging upon attacks is a notable effect that has been seen a few times across Magic history, though this writer fondly remembers the Mono-Red Aggro decks featuring Cavalcade of Calamity from that era of Standard as his favorite of the archetype.

9. Mahadi, Emporium Master (Etched Foil) – Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur’s Gate

Market Price: $3.12

A fun budget commander option in Rakdos () colors, this 3/3 Devil from Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur’s Gate delivers you Treasure tokens during each of your end steps based on the number of creatures that died that turn.

Of course, the best way to abuse this creature is to play it after a critical board wipe, but it also works if you use sorcery-speed removal during your turn to pick off critical threats from your opponents, who will rue the day they visited Mahadi’s emporium. Just don't call him a cat.

8. Henzie "Toolbox" Torre (Extended Art) – New Capenna Commander

Market Price: $3.18

The unexpected grand champion of EDHREC’s 2026 March Commandness Tournament beat out some of the most iconic and powerful commanders of all time… but how?

This Jund () Devil Rogue simply has a lot going for him. He plays in an unusual space with the unique-to-New-Capenna blitz mechanic, he’s well-statted as a 3/3 for only three mana, he allows for a lot of exploration and fun deckbuilding thanks to being three colors, and he also lowers the cost of your blitz spells so long as you play him from the command zone multiple times in a game. Sounds like a top-tier Devil to me.

7. Fiendish Duo – Murders at Karlov Manor Commander

Market Price: $3.36

Tacking a one-way Furnace of Rath on a 5/5 Devil creature sounds like a good time for its caster, and that is exactly why this Murders at Karlov Manor Commander Devil is worth over three dollars on the secondary market.

This card was actually printed twice before in unusual capacities: once in Game Night 2019, its first printing, and once as a Japan-exclusive “prerelease-at-home” promo. For this list, however, we’ll be including the first widely available English printing, the MKM Commander one.

6. Sin Prodder (Prerelease Promo) – Shadows over Innistrad

Market Price: $4.04

The Innistrad block introduced the vast majority of Devils to Magic, as there were only the three aforementioned Devils printed before that set. This prerelease Devil introduced a notable twist on everyone’s favorite black creature, Bob (Dark Confidant), by forcing foes to make the decision about whether you keep the extra card each turn.

This card is especially fun in Commander, as politicking can turn to backstabbing quickly depending on who has the most life... or how far ahead or behind your Devil deck is.

5. Raphael, Fiendish Savior (Prerelease Promo) – Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur’s Gate

Market Price: $6.49

While the non-prerelease version of this Baldur’s Gate 3 antagonist can be had for under a dollar, the prerelease version is safely ensconced as the fifth-most valuable Devil card ever.

A supremely enjoyable build-around in Commander, as Raphael allows you to beef up your other Devils, Demons, Imps, and Tieflings, and the rakish Devil even tacks on the eminently useful lifelink keyword for good measure. “Here come the claws!”

4. Pain Distributor – March of the Machine Commander

Market Price: $6.86

An eminently useful piece of tech for Commander, this one should pretty much be an auto-include in most decks that feature red, no matter their theme, with very few exceptions.

This 2/3 Devil with menace nets you a Treasure token whenever a player casts their first spell each turn, which, as you would expect, happens quite a lot during the course of a Commander game. As such, the pain this Devil distributes will most likely be aimed at all of your opponents due to the fact that you’ll be so far ahead on mana.

3. Auntie Blyte, Bad Influence – Jumpstart 2022

Market Price: $9.32

A strange and delightful 2/2 legendary Devil Advisor from Jumpstart 2022, Auntie Blyte, Bad Influence rewards you for doing one of the most red things imaginable: hurting yourself and pretending it was all part of the plan.

Whenever a source you control deals damage to you, Auntie Blyte gets that many +1/+1 counters, which can then be turned around and fired at any target. That makes her a fun, weird Commander build-around for cards like Manabarbs, Roiling Vortex, Jackal Pup, Sulfuric Vortex, and other effects that make everyone at the table wonder why you keep volunteering to be set on fire. A bad influence, indeed.

2. Mayhem Devil – Prints of Darkness Secret Lair Drop

Market Price: $11.82

Extremely fun artwork headlines this Secret Lair Devil from 2024, which was originally found in 2019’s War of the Spark. The anchor of the Rakdos Sacrifice Standard deck from its era, this card highlights just how common sacrificing permanents has become in Magic.

Not only does it punish sacrifice-based decks, it also supercharges your own sacrifice strategies—such as if you’re playing Korvold, Fae-Cursed King as your commander—making this one Devil that truly thrives in chaos and mayhem.

1. Asmodeus the Archfiend (Foil Ampersand Promo) – Adventures in the Forgotten Realms

Market Price: $43.47

The most valuable Devil by far is one of the big bads from 2021’s Adventures in the Forgotten Realms set, a 6/6 Devil God that does a serviceable impression of one of the strongest card-draw spells of all time: the triple-black enchantment Necropotence.

This version of Asmodeus boasts the eminently rare Dungeons & Dragons ampersand etched onto its foil finish and is the 14^th-most valuable card with that special finish.

Devils, But Not in Disguise

While just over 50 Devils might seem like a pretty solid rate, Angels more than quintuple that amount across Magic history, though, of course, they had quite the head start. With not many kindred enhancers (Raphael being one of the few that springs to mind), perhaps Wizards of the Coast will continue to print some interesting Devils when it’s thematically sensible. Until then, fans of these devilish creatures will just have to make do. Hey, at least these are among the least expensive “most valuable” creatures so far!